This is one of those home topics where the obvious approach isn't always the right one. A better starting place is push versus self-propelled versus electric.
Push versus self-propelled versus electric
Start by thinking about push versus self-propelled versus electric. It's easy to skip this step and go straight to buying something, but the households that end up happiest with the result usually spend a little time here first.
Yard size thresholds
Yard size thresholds matters more than it might seem at first. Getting this part right tends to save a second round of changes later.
Storage space
Start by thinking about storage space. It's easy to skip this step and go straight to buying something, but the households that end up happiest with the result usually spend a little time here first.
Expert tip
Write down what isn't working before you start changing anything. It's easy to lose track of the original problem once new options are on the table.
Frequently asked questions
Does this apply to rented homes as well as owned ones?
Most of the ideas here don't require permanent changes, so they translate reasonably well to a rental, though it's worth checking your lease before anything involving drilling or fixed installation.
What's the most common mistake people make here?
Skipping the planning step and going straight to a purchase or a big rearrangement, then having to undo part of it once the practical issues show up.
How long does this usually take to get right?
It depends on the size of the space and how much you're changing at once, but most households see the biggest improvement from the first few adjustments rather than from doing everything at once.